The Exuberant Kennedy Years. The Democratic
senator John F. Kennedy, asserting that he wanted to "get the country
moving again," won the presidency in a narrow victory over
Vice-President Richard M. Nixon in 1960. The charismatic Kennedy
stimulated a startling burst of national enthusiasm and aroused high hopes
among the young and the disadvantaged. Within 3 years his Peace Corps sent
about 10,000 Americans (mostly young people) abroad to work in 46
countries. Kennedy's Alliance for Progress proposed a 10-year plan to
transform the economies of the Latin American nations (partially
successful, it sunk out of sight during the Vietnam War). He also proposed
massive tariff cuts between the increasingly protectionist European Common
Market and the world at large. (The so-called Kennedy Round of tariff
negotiations concluded in 1967 with the largest and widest tariff cuts in
modern history.) In June 1961, Kennedy pulled together the disparate,
disorganized space effort by giving it a common goal: placing an American
on the moon. Responding enthusiastically, Congress poured out billions of
dollars to finance the project. (After the Apollo program succeeded, on
July 20, 1969, in landing astronauts on the moon, the space effort
remained in motion, if at a reduced pace.)
Kennedy blundered into a major defeat within 3 months of entering the
White House. He kept in motion a plan sponsored by the Central
Intelligence Agency (CIA) and begun by the Eisenhower administration to
land an invasion force in Cuba, which under Fidel Castro had become a
Communist state and a Soviet state. The Bay of Pigs invasion failed,
utterly and completely. The force was quickly smashed when it struggled
onto the beaches of the Bay of Pigs in April 1961. During the succeeding 2
years, Kennedy labored to break the rigid cold-war relationship with the
USSR. In October 1962, however, he discovered that the Soviets were
rapidly building missile emplacements in Cuba. Surrounding the island with
a naval blockade, he induced the Soviets to desist, and the sites were
eventually dismantled. The relieved world discovered that, when pushed to
the crisis point, the two major powers could stop short of nuclear war.
This Cuban Missile Crisis effectively ended the cold war.
The atomic bomb now seemed defused, and Moscow seemed ready to
negotiate on crucial issues (perhaps, it was suggested 15 years later, to
give the Soviets time to build a far more powerful armaments system). A
new and more relaxed relationship developed slowly into the U.S.-Soviet dιtente
that emerged in the late 1960s and persisted through the 1970s. A test-ban
treaty, the Moscow Agreement, signed in October 1963 symbolized the
opening of the new relationship. Three of the world's nuclear powers
(Great Britain, the United States, and the USSR the fourth, France,
did not sign) agreed to end the detonation of atomic explosions in the
atmosphere.
In this new environment of security, American culture, long restrained
by the sense of team spirit and conformity that the crises of depression,
war, and cold war had induced, broke loose into multiplying swift changes.
People now began talking excitedly of "doing their own thing."
The media were filled with discussions of the rapidly changing styles of
dress and behavior among the young; of the "new woman" (or the
"liberated woman," as she became known); of new sexual practices
and attitudes and new styles of living. The sense of community faded.
Romanticism shaped the new mood, with its emphasis on instinct and impulse
rather than reason, ecstatic release rather than restraint, individualism
and self-gratification rather than group discipline.
Race Relations during the 1960s and 1970s.
Race relations was one area with great potential for violence, although
many black leaders stressed nonviolence. Since the mid-1950s, King and
others had been leading disciplined mass protests of black Americans in
the South against segregation, emphasizing appeals to the conscience of
the white majority (see civil rights movement). The appeals of these
leaders and judicial rulings on the illegality of segregationist practices
were vital parts of the Second Reconstruction, which transformed the role
and status of black Americans, energizing every other cultural movement as
well. At the same time, southern white resistance to the ending of
segregation, with its attendant violence, stimulated a northern-dominated
Congress to enact (1957) the first civil rights law since 1875, creating
the Commission on Civil Rights and prohibiting interference with the right
to vote (blacks were still massively disenfranchised in many southern
states). A second enactment (1960) provided federal referees to aid blacks
in registering for and voting in federal elections. In 1962, President
Kennedy dispatched troops to force the University of Mississippi (a state
institution) to admit James Meredith, a black student. At the same time,
he forbade racial or religious discrimination in federally financed
housing.
Kennedy then asked Congress to enact a law to guarantee equal access to
all public accommodations, forbid discrimination in any state program
receiving federal aid, and outlaw discrimination in employment and voting.
After Kennedy's death, President Johnson prodded Congress into enacting
(August 1965) a Voting Rights Act that eliminated all qualifying tests for
registration that had as their objective limiting the right to vote to
whites. Thereafter, massive voter registration drives in the South sent
the proportion of registered blacks spurting upward from less than 30% to
over 53% in 1966.
The civil rights phase of the black revolution had reached its
legislative and judicial summit. Then, from 1964 to 1968, more than a
hundred American cities were swept by race riots, which included
dynamitings, guerrilla warfare, and huge conflagrations, as the anger of
the northern black community at its relatively low income, high
unemployment, and social exclusion exploded. At this violent expression of
hopelessness the northern white community drew back rapidly from its
reformist stance on the race issue (the so-called white backlash). In
1968, swinging rightward in its politics, the nation chose as president
Richard M. Nixon, who was not in favor of using federal power to aid the
disadvantaged. Individual advancement, he believed, had to come by
individual effort.
Nonetheless, fundamental changes continued in relations between white
and black. Although the economic disparity in income did not disappear
indeed, it widened, as unemployment within black ghettos and among black
youths remained at a high level in the 1970s white-dominated American
culture opened itself significantly toward black people. Entrance
requirements for schools and colleges were changed; hundreds of
communities sought to work out equitable arrangements to end de facto
segregation in the schools (usually with limited success, and to the
accompaniment of a white flight to different school districts); graduate
programs searched for black applicants; and integration in jobs and in the
professions expanded. Blacks moved into the mainstream of the party
system, for the voting-rights enactments transformed national politics.
The daily impact of television helped make blacks, seen in shows and
commercial advertisements, seem an integral part of a pluralistic nation.
Mexican Americans and Puerto Ricans were also becoming more prominent
in American life. Reaching the level of 9 million by the 1960s,
Spanish-surnamed Americans had become the second largest ethnic minority;
they, too, were asserting their right to equitable treatment in politics,
in culture, and in economic affairs.
Foreign Policy under Nixon. When Richard M.
Nixon became president in 1969, he profoundly changed U.S. foreign policy.
The new theme was withdrawal from commitments around the globe. Nixon
revived the kind of nationalist, unilateral foreign policy that, since
Theodore Roosevelt, presidents of his political tradition had preferred.
With Henry Kissinger as an advisor and later as secretary of state, he
began a kind of balance-of-power diplomacy. He preferred to keep the
United States free of lasting commitments (even to former allies) so that
it could move back and forth between the other four power centers
Europe, the USSR, China, and Japan and maintain world equilibrium.
Nixon soon announced his "Vietnamization" policy, which meant
a slow withdrawal of American forces and a heavy building up of the South
Vietnam army. Nonetheless, in the 3 years 1969-71, 15,000 more Americans
died fighting in Vietnam. In April 1970, Nixon launched a huge invasion of
Cambodia in a vain attempt to clear out communist "sanctuaries."
Then, most dramatically, he deflected world attention by ending the
long American quarantine of Communist China, visiting Beijing in February
1972 for general discussions on all matters of mutual concern a move
that led to the establishment (1979) of diplomatic relations. At the same
time, he continued the heavy bombing attacks on North Vietnam that he had
reinstituted in late 1971. He brushed aside as "without binding force
or effect" the congressional attempt to halt American fighting in
Vietnam by repealing the Tonkin Gulf Resolution of 1964, which had
authorized Johnson to begin military operations. Nixon asserted that as
commander in chief he could do anything he deemed necessary to protect the
lives of American troops still in Vietnam.
In May 1972, Nixon became the first American president to consult with
Soviet leaders in Moscow, leaving with major agreements relating to trade,
cooperation in space programs and other fields of technology, cultural
exchanges, and many other areas. He became more popular as prosperity
waxed and as negotiations with the North Vietnamese in Paris seemed to be
bringing the Vietnam War to a halt. In 1972 the Democrats nominated for
the presidency Sen. George McGovern of South Dakota, a man who for years
had advocated women's rights, black equality, and greater power for the
young. With the nation's increasingly conservative cultural mood and the
trend in Vietnam, Nixon won a massive landslide victory. In January 1973,
Nixon announced a successful end to the Vietnamese negotiations: a
cease-fire was established and an exchange of prisoners provided for.
Watergate. Few presidents could ever have
been more confident of a successful second term than Richard Nixon at this
point. But before the year 1973 was out, his administration had fallen
into the gravest scandal in American history. By March 1974 the stunning
events of the Watergate crisis and associated villainies had led to the
resignation of more than a dozen high officials including the
vice-president (for the acceptance of graft) and the indictment or
conviction of many others. Their criminal acts included burglary, forgery,
illegal wiretapping and electronic surveillance, perjury, obstruction of
justice, bribery, and many other offenses.
These scandalous events had their roots in the long Democratic years
beginning with Roosevelt, when the American presidency had risen in a kind
of solitary majesty to become overwhelmingly the most powerful agency of
government. All that was needed for grave events to occur was the
appearance in the White House of individuals who would put this immense
power to its full use. Lyndon Johnson was such a man, for he was driven by
gargantuan dreams. One result was America's disastrous war in Vietnam.
Richard Nixon, too, believed in the imperial authority of the presidency.
He envisioned politics as an arena in which he represented true
Americanism and his critics the forces of subversion.
At least from 1969, Nixon operated on the principle that, at his
direction, federal officials could violate the law. On June 17, 1972,
members of his Special Investigations Unit (created without congressional
authorization) were arrested while burglarizing the national Democratic
party offices in the Watergate office-and-apartment complex in Washington,
D.C.
A frantic effort then began, urged on by the president, to cover up
links between the Watergate burglars and the executive branch. This
cover-up constituted an obstruction of justice, a felony. This fact,
however, was kept hidden through many months of congressional hearings
(begun in May 1973) into the burglaries. Televised, they were watched by
multitudes. The American people learned of millions of dollars jammed into
office safes and sluiced about from hand to hand to finance shady
dealings, of elaborate procedures for covering tracks and destroying
papers, and of tapes recording the president's conversations with his
aides.
With Watergate eroding Nixon's prestige, Congress finally halted
American fighting in Indochina by cutting off funds (after Aug. 15, 1973)
to finance the bombing of Cambodia, which had continued after the Vietnam
Peace Agreement. Thus, America's longest war was finally concluded. In
November 1973, Congress passed, over the president's veto, the War Powers
Act, sharply limiting the executive's freedom of action in initiating
foreign wars. When Vice-President Spiro T. Agnew resigned his office on
Oct. 10, 1973, Nixon, with Senate ratification, appointed Gerald R. Ford
to replace him.
On July 24, 1974, the Supreme Court ordered Nixon to deliver his Oval
Office tapes to Congress. This order, in turn, led to the revelation that
he had directly approved the cover-up. Informed by Republican
congressional leaders of his certain conviction in forthcoming impeachment
proceedings, Richard Nixon resigned the presidency on Aug. 9, 1974.
The Reagan Era. The release of the U.S.
hostages in Iran on the same day as Reagan's inauguration launched the new
administration on a wave of euphoria. Aided by a torrent of goodwill
following an attempt on his life in March 1981, Reagan persuaded the
Congress to cut government spending for welfare, increase outlays for
defense, reduce taxes, and deregulate private enterprise. His "supply
side" economic policy (dubbed "Reaganomics" by the media)
anticipated that lower taxes and a freer market would stimulate investment
and that a prosperous, expanding economy would increase employment, reduce
inflation, and provide enough government revenue to eliminate future
budget deficits.
The "Reagan Revolution," combined with the tight money
policies of the Federal Reserve System, initially dismayed those who hoped
for a reversal of the economic stagnation of the 1970s. Although high
interest rates helped cut inflation from more than 12% in 1980 to less
than 7% in 1982, unemployment rose from 7% to 11% the highest rate
since 1940 and the annual federal deficit soared to $117 billion,
almost twice as high as it had ever been. The United States experienced
its worst recession since the 1930s. Beginning in 1983, however, the
economy rebounded sharply. By the end of 1986, 11 million new jobs had
been created, the consumer price index had dropped from 13.1% in 1979 to
just 4.1%, and the Dow-Jones average had climbed to an all-time high.
The Reagan recovery did little for rural America or for the declining
industrial regions of the Midwest. In the first half of the 1980s, 8.4
million people joined the ranks of the poor, an increase of 40%. Nearly 33
million Americans one out of every seven were reported as living
below the poverty line. But the bulk of middle-class America, buoyed by
low inflation and its own prosperity, gave the president high marks for
his economic program. Conservatives were pleased with his appointments to
the federal bench, his declarations of faith in traditional values, and
his proud patriotism.
In practice, and often in response to congressional pressure, Reagan
balanced his ardent anti-Communist rhetoric with generally restrained
foreign-policy actions. He denounced the USSR as an "evil
empire" but ended the embargo on grain sales to the Soviets imposed
by President Carter after the invasion of Afghanistan. While presiding
over the largest peacetime military buildup in U.S. history, he observed
the still-unratified SALT II arms control treaty negotiated by his
predecessor. He sent American troops to Lebanon as part of a peacekeeping
force but withdrew them after 241 marines were killed in a bomb attack in
October 1983.
Only in Central America and the Caribbean did the president's actions
match his rhetoric. To quash a Communist revolt in El Salvador, Reagan
committed military advisors and furnished financial aid to the Salvadoran
government. Determined to oust Nicaragua's pro-Communist Sandinista
government, he gave covert aid to antigovernment rebels known as the
contras in defiance of a congressional ban on such aid. In 1983 he
used military force to topple a pro-Cuban regime on the Caribbean island
of Grenada.
Reagan and his running mate, George Bush, easily defeated their
Democratic opponents, Walter Mondale and Geraldine Ferraro, in 1984, but
the Democrats maintained control of Congress and the president offered
fewer domestic initiatives during his second term. Partisan wrangling over
what parts of the budget to cut in order to reduce the staggering federal
deficit led to passage of the Gramm-Rudman Act (1985), which mandated
automatic, across-the-board spending cuts over a period of years. The
Supreme Court declared the automatic cuts unconstitutional in 1986,
however, and repeated failure by the president and Congress to agree on
budget reductions kept the deficit at record levels. Disputes over the
control of trade policy also worsened the imbalance of imports over
exports, which rose to $161 billion in 1987.
Tax reductions and defense spending, however, kept the economy booming.
Reagan boosted defense spending 35% above the 1980 level, and in 1986 he
secured congressional approval for a major income tax reform law that
further cut taxes on corporations and wealthy individuals.
At the end of Reagan's tenure the GOP could boast that his
administration had helped create 16.5 million new jobs, bring down the
unemployment rate to a 17-year low, cut double-digit inflation down to
about 4%, and raise the gross national product by one-third. Democrats, on
the other hand, could criticize "Reaganomics" for promoting
prosperity at the expense of the poor and the nation's future well-being.
The number of people below the poverty line rose by 8 million, and their
lot was made worse by cuts of nearly $50 billion in social welfare
programs. Reductions in subsidized housing from $30 billion in 1981 to $7
billion in 1988 made homelessness part of the national lexicon, and the
number of Americans without any health-care insurance rose to 37 million.
By borrowing rather than taxing to rearm, Reagan mortgaged the financial
future. The cost of servicing the national debt rose from 8.9% of all
federal outlays in 1980 to 14.8% in 1989. Moreover, persistent trade and
budget deficits made the country a debtor nation for the first time since
1914.
During its eight years in office the administration had a significant
impact on the composition of the federal judiciary. President Reagan
appointed three conservatives to the Supreme Court and elevated
conservative William Rehnquist to chief justice. Overall, he filled about
half of the 700 federal judgeships, most of them with conservative
appointees.
A major scandal of Reagan's second term was the Iran-contra affair, in
which national security advisor John M. Poindexter, Marine Lt. Col. Oliver
North, and other officials were involved in a secret scheme to sell arms
to Iran, diverting some of the proceeds to the contra rebels in Nicaragua.
Investigation by Congress in 1987 led to the prosecution of Poindexter and
North and damaged the administration's image.
Ironically, developments in foreign affairs during Ronald Reagan's
second term led this most anti-Communist of presidents into a new,
harmonious relationship with the Soviet Union and to sign the first
superpower treaty that actually reduced nuclear armaments. Soviet leader
Mikhail Gorbachev, determined to relax tensions with the West, met with
Reagan in 1985 and 1986; in 1987 they signed the Intermediate Nuclear
Forces Treaty, and in 1988 a triumphant Reagan traveled to Moscow for a
fourth summit and further arms-reduction talks.
The Clinton Administration. Despite the
movement into Washington of new people with fresh ideas and high optimism,
the Clinton administration got off to a slow, unsteady start. However much
Clinton wished to stress domestic affairs, crises in Bosnia, Haiti,
Somalia, and Russia forced him to focus on the volatile, multipolar world
of the post-cold war era, and his actions seemed uncertain and irresolute
to many. At the same time Clinton backed down from his promise to prohibit
discrimination against gays in the military and for lack of revenue
reneged on his pledge to provide tax relief for the middle class.
Defeated by Congress on his proposals to stimulate the economy, Clinton
then won by the narrowest of margins a highly compromised federal budget
plan to reduce the deficit. The president had more success in persuading
Congress to enact family leave and "motor voter" registration,
to approve the North American Free Trade Agreement, and to confirm his
nominations of Ruth Bader Ginsburg and Stephen G. Breyer to the Supreme
Court. However, still dogged by accusations of infidelity and sexual
harassment while governor of Arkansas, by questions involving his wife's
past success in commodity trading, and by allegations of wrongdoing by the
Whitewater Development Company a failed real estate venture in which
the Clintons had invested the president in 1994 faced new reverses.
Clinton saw his elaborate plan to reform the nation's health-care system
sink in Congress, his proposal for campaign finance reform stalled by the
Senate, and his wife, Hillary Rodham Clinton, become a controversial
political issue. Despite enactment of an omnibus federal crime bill, as
well as successful and bloodless military operations that checked an Iraqi
threat of a renewed Gulf War and unseated an outlaw junta in Haiti, the
1994 off-year elections proved a sweeping repudiation of Clinton and the
Democrats. The Republicans gained control of Congress for the first time
since the 1952 elections. Trumpeting their "Contract with
America," a comprehensive plan to reduce federal spending and
regulation, and to balance the budget and eliminate the deficit while
simultaneously cutting income and capital-gains taxes, the Republican
Congress eagerly clashed with Clinton in 1995.
But Clinton, an adept politician, outmaneuvered his GOP opponents. He
succeeded in picturing the "Contract with America" as extremist
measures that would unduly benefit the rich at the expense of the elderly
and needy and his own more moderate proposals as being both compassionate
and fiscally responsible. At the same time he adopted as his own various
Republican issues that were designed to appeal to middle-class Americans
worried about the decline in the nation's morals and values. Clinton
appeared more surefooted in responding to events abroad as his
administration helped to arrange a peace treaty between the warring
parties in Bosnia and to move negotiations forward in Israel and Northern
Ireland. Fortunate, above all, in presiding over an improving economy
with a growing GDP, falling unemployment, and the lowest "misery
index" since 1969 Clinton ran unopposed for the Democratic
nomination in 1996. He easily won reelection over the Republican nominee,
former Senate majority leader Robert Dole, and the Reform party's Ross
Perot. A majority of Americans, however, continued to have doubts about
Clinton's character and to fear both Democratic tax-and-spend programs and
Republican efforts to curtail such entitlements as Medicare and Social
Security. Accordingly, the lowest turnout of voters since 1924 returned
Clinton to the White House with just 49% of the popular vote. Again facing
a Republican-controlled House and Senate, Clinton came to an agreement
with Congress on a bill that significantly modified the welfare system in
place since the mid-1930s, and on a budget that lowered taxes on both the
wealthy and the middle classes, allocated less to the poor, and further
reduced the federal deficit. Although bothered by old allegations of
sexual and financial improprieties by Clinton, as well as new ones of
violations of campaign contribution rules, many voters in a peaceful and
prosperous United States opted to maintain the status quo.
In 1998 the new set of sexual-misconduct charges threatened President
Clinton. Whitewater special prosecutor Kenneth Starr spent the year
investigating these allegations, questioned the president in front of a
grand jury, and delivered a report to Congress recommending impeachment on
the grounds of perjury and obstruction of justice. Congress initiated an
impeachment investigation. Despite the results of the 1998 midterm
elections, which demonstrated once again that the electorate did not want
impeachment of the president, the Republican-controlled House voted
(December 19) largely along party lines in favor of impeachment.
Clinton's trial by the Senate lasted five weeks, from Jan. 7 to Feb.
12, 1999. The impeachment managers appointed by the House presented the
case against the president, charging him with perjury and obstruction of
justice. Clinton's lawyers argued that the charges stemmed from his
private life and that the offenses fell short of the "high crimes and
misdemeanors" stipulated by the Constitution as grounds for
impeachment. In the final vote the senators found the president not guilty
of perjury by a majority of 55-45, and not guilty of obstruction of
justice by a vote of 50-50; in both cases the results were far short of
the two-thirds majority necessary for conviction. The Democrats all voted
for acquittal. On the first count they were joined by 10 Republicans, and
on the second by 5.
No sooner was the impeachment crisis over than the country faced a
major foreign policy challenge. After repeated Serb attrocities against
ethnic Albanians in the Yugoslav province of Kosovo, President Clinton
demanded that Yugoslavian president Slobodan Milosevic gree to allow a
NATO peacekeeping force in Kosovo. When Milosevic refused, the United
States and its allies launched (Mar. 24, 1999) air strikes against
Yugoslavia in an effort to force his compliance. After more than two
months of daily bombing raids, Yugoslavia agreed to accept NATO's terms on
June 3, 1999.
In April China's prime minister Zhu Rongji visited the United States at
a time when American-Chinese relations were troubled by U.S. objections to
China's human rights policies, charges of espionage activities by Chinese
agents in the United States, and China's condemnation of U.S. actions
against Yugoslavia. Relations between the countries were further
complicated when NATO bombs hit the Chinese embassy in Belgrade in May.
Harmony was restored at a meeting between President Clinton and Chinese
President Jiang Zemin in September at the Asia-Pacific Economic
Cooperation summit in New Zealand, and normal trade relations between
China and the United States were established in 2000. Other items on the
president's foreign policy agenda fared less well. In December 1999 the
World Trade Organization rejected his proposals for a new set of rules
governing international commerce, and peace negotiations between Israel
and the Palestinian National Authority dragged on through the summer and
fell apart amid renewed violence in the fall of 2000.
Clinton spent much of his final months in office negotiating to avoid
possible criminal action against him by Robert W. Ray, who had succeeded
Kenneth Starr as independent counsel, and in fashioning his legacy his
hoped-for place in history. In exchange for avoiding prosecution, the
president admitted making false and misleading statements while testifying
under oath and agreed to pay a fine and have his license to practice law
in Arkansas suspended. And while his critics emphasized that the president
left office having incurred enormous personal distrust, his supporters
countered that Clinton ended his term with the highest job-approval rating
of any modern president.
Both were right. While most Americans loathed the president's personal
behavior, they supported to an even greater extent the Clinton policies
that brought them peace, and especially prosperity. For during the Clinton
years unemployment dropped from 7.5% to 4%, the Dow Jones Industrial
Average of stocks rose from 3,200 to more than 11,000, and the federal
budget went from a quarter-trillion-dollar deficit to a surplus nearly
that large. And while the stock market exploded, the welfare state
imploded, as Clinton made good on his promise to "end welfare as we
know it," to repeal the federal guarantees of the Aid to Families
with Dependent Children program. At the same time, he bungled, and lost,
his most important initiative, universal health insurance (leaving more
than 44 million Americans uninsured), never pushed strongly for
large-scale investments in education and job training or devised an energy
policy, and avoided risking his political capital on reforming social
security and Medicare. Ironically, his main achievements welfare
reform, free-trade treaties, and a balanced budget were each largely
initiated and supported by the Republican party.
As Clinton himself rued, great presidents are associated with great
crises war and economic depression and he faced nothing of that
magnitude. Nevertheless, good presidents are ones who make the most of
what they do face and who move public opinion in their direction. Clinton
failed to do that. Rather than chart a bold new course, he followed the
currents of popular opinion. Rather than set the terms and tone of public
debate, he governed by polls. Rather leading by example, Clinton's
behavior and frequent efforts to mislead embarrassed most Americans. And
so, historians may ultimately judge, many Americans concluded that the
Clinton presidency was one of both accomplishment and disappointment.
The Election of 2000. In 2000 attention was
focused throughout the year on the presidential election. Challenges from
Sen. John McCain of Arizona on the Republican side and former N.J. senator
Bill Bradley on the Democratic side were eliminated in the primaries,
leaving the way clear for front runners Republican Texas governor George
W. Bush and Democratic vice-president Al Gore. At the conventions in
August Bush selected former secretary of defense Richard B. Cheney as his
running mate, while Gore chose Connecticut senator Joseph I. Lieberman.
Third-party candidates included Ralph Nader (Green party) and Pat Buchanan
(Reform party).
The mixed record of the Clinton administration played a key role in the
election. With the economy booming, Vice-President Gore should have
enjoyed an enormous advantage in the election. However, the shadow of the
Clinton scandals and some liabilities of Gore's own with campaign
fund-raising allowed the untested Governor Bush to make
"character" more important than "experience" for many
voters. In terms of issues, both candidates cleaved to the center. This
produced an election closer than any in modern history. It was so close,
in fact, that the actual outcome was finally determined by court decision
more than a month after the election.
Election-night returns on November 7 showed Gore leading in both
electoral votes (255 to 246) and popular votes (48,707,413 to 48,609,640),
but neither candidate had the 270 electoral votes necessary for victory.
The outcome was too close to call in three states Oregon, New Mexico,
and Florida and it was clear that Florida's 25 electoral votes would
determine the winner. The vote in Florida, as in the nation at large, was
extremely close. The initial count showed Bush leading by 1,784 votes, a
margin so small that it required a recount under Florida state law. The
recount took several days to complete. During this time, manual recounts
were ordered by the courts in several counties where Democratic voters
initiated legal action on the ground that the original vote count had been
distorted by poorly designed ballots or faulty voting machines. When the
official recount was completed and the absentee ballots were added in,
Bush's lead had narrowed to 930. Then, on November 21, the Florida Supreme
Court ruled that the results of manual recounts in three strongly
Democratic counties should be included in the final tally, and the court
extended the date for certification of the vote to November 27. The Bush
campaign, arguing that the hand counts were being conducted in an
arbitrary manner and that the Florida Supreme Court had acted improperly
in extending the certification deadline, appealed the decision the U.S.
Supreme Court. On November 27, with the hand recounts still incomplete,
Florida's Republican secretary of state, Katherine Harris, declared Bush
the winner in Florida by a margin of 537 votes. The Gore campaign
contested her ruling in the courts; at the same time, the
Republican-dominated state legislature threatened to bypass the courts by
naming its own slate of electors favorable to Bush.
On December 4 the U.S. Supreme Court vacated the November 21 ruling of
the Florida Supreme Court and sent the case back to that court for
clarification. Meanwhile, the Gore campaign's appeal against the vote
certification by Secretary Harris had been turned down by Florida circuit
court judge N. Sanders Sauls. On December 8, responding favorably to an
appeal from the Gore campaign against Judge Sauls's decision, the Florida
Supreme Court ordered an immediate manual recount of "undervotes"
(ballots that registered no presidential vote in the machine count)
throughout the state. The following day the U.S. Supreme Court ordered a
halt to the recount; then, on December 12, the U.S. justices voted 5-4 to
bar any further recounts. On the next day, December 13, Gore conceded the
election, and Florida's electoral votes went to Bush. In the final tally,
Bush had five more electoral votes than Gore (271-266) but lost the
popular vote by a margin of more than 500,000. Bush thus became the first
candidate since Benjamin Harrison in 1888 to win the presidency while
losing the popular vote.
The Bush administration took office in January 2001. The new president
named a cabinet that included both conservatives and moderates, but
quickly and methodically began to promote an agenda that reversed many of
the policies established during the previous administration. President
Bush laid special emphasis on his plan for a $1.6 trillion tax cut, which
he said would give a boost to a faltering U.S. economy. Critics countered
that since the tax reductions would occur gradually over a 10-year period,
no immediate relief could be expected; they also claimed that Bush, by
continually warning about the danger of a recession and the need of a tax
cut to prevent it, was actually helping to bring on the economic downturn
that he feared. Indeed the first months of the new administration
coincided with an end to the booming economy of the 1990s and the
emergence of a bear market on Wall Street. The House passed the
president's tax cut in its entirety in March 2001, but the Senate would
agree only to a $1.2 trillion reduction when it took up consideration of
the plan a short time later. The administration's budget increased
spending for education and the military but cut funding for
transportation, agriculture, and environmental protection. The new
administration also made proposals to relax some rules relating to oil
drilling on public lands, it lowered drinking water standards, and it
canceled a plan to regulate carbon dioxide emissions by power plants.
In foreign affairs the Bush administration showed a tendency to pull
back from international commitments, moving to limit U.S. peacekeeping
activities in the Balkans, to reduce economic assistance to Russia, and to
abandon an effort to reach an understanding with North Korea. America's
allies in Europe reacted negatively to the president's repudiation of the
Kyoto treaty on global warming, as well as to Defense Secretary Donald
Rumsfeld's criticisms of an independent European defense force. Tensions
with China, already high because of proposed weapons sales by the United
States to Taiwan, were further aggravated by a collision (April 2001)
between a U.S. surveillance plane and a Chinese fighter off the coast of
China that resulted in the death of a Chinese airman. An expression of
regret by the United States brought about the release of the American crew
(who had landed at a Chinese airfield), but China remained dissatisfied
about the Taiwan issue and about U.S. surveillance flights close to the
Chinese mainland, which were viewed by the Chinese government as
violations of their airspace.
In May, Republican Sen. James Jeffords of Vermont declared himself an
Independent; this caused the GOP to lose control of the Senate, which had
been evenly split between the two parties, with Vice-President Cheney
casting the tie-breaking vote. On June 7 the president signed the tax cut
into law; in the final version, arrived at by agreement between the two
houses, the total value of the legislation was put $1.35 trillion.
Harvard Sitkoff
Bibliography:
General
Blum, J. M., et al., The National Experience, 8th ed. (1993); Curti,
M. E., The Growth of American Thought, 3d ed. (1964; repr. 1981); Foner, Eric,
The Story of American Freedom (1998); French, Michael, U.S. Economic History since 1945 (1997);
Garraty, J. A., The
American Nation, 8th ed. (1994); Heilbroner, R. L., and Singer, A., The
Economic Transformation of America: 1600 to Present, 2d ed. (1984);
Hofstadter, R., The American Political Tradition and the Men Who Made
It, 2d ed. (1973); McDougall, W. A., Promised Land, Crusader State:
The American Encounter with the World since 1776 (1997); Milner, C.
A., II, et al., Oxford History of the American West (1994);
Morison, S. E., and Commager, H. S., The Growth of the American
Republic, 2 vols., 7th ed. (1980).
To (c.)1860
Bailyn, B., The Peopling of British North America (1986); Boorstin,
D. J., The Americans: The National Experience (1965; repr. 1985);
Elkins, S., and McKitrick, E., The Age of Federalism (1993);
Genovese, E., Roll, Jordan, Roll (1974).
From (c.)1860
Biles, R., A New Deal for the American People (1991); Ehrman, J., The
Rise of Neoconservatism (1995); Foner, E., Reconstruction
(1988; repr. 1989); Freedman, S. G., The Inheritance (1996); Higham,
J., Strangers in the Land: Patterns of American Nativism, 18601925,
2d ed. (1965; repr. 1988); Hodgson, G., The World Turned Right Side Up
(1996); Hofstadter, R., The Age of Reform: From Bryan to F.D.R.
(1955); Kennedy, D. M., Freedom from Fear: The American People in
Depression and War, 19291945 (1999); Leuchtenburg, W. E., Franklin
D. Roosevelt and the New Deal, 19321940 (1963) and In the Shadow
of FDR: From Harry Truman to Ronald Reagan (1985); McPherson, J. M., Battle
Cry of Freedom: The Civil War Era (1988; repr. 1989); Nevins, A., Ordeal
of the Union, 8 vols. (194771); Patterson, J. T., Grand
Expectations: The United States, 194574 (1996); Powers, R. G., Not
without Honor: The History of American Anticommunism (1995); Sitkoff,
Harvard, The Struggle for Black Equality, 19541992 (1993); Traxel, David,
1898: Birth of the American Century (1998); Wiebe,
R. H., The Search for Order, 18771920 (1967; repr. 1980).