Positive
signals from Haiti, now for concrete action
Analysis |
Rickey Singh
Sunday, August 14, 2005
|
With parliamentary and
presidential elections in Haiti on the horizon, possibly in
November, there are indications of significant shifts in
policies , both in Washington and Port au Prince, to improve the
human rights climate in that Caribbean nation.
 |
| Rickey Singh |
This includes ending the
policy of long imprisonment, without charges and court trials,
of presumed political prisoners and advocates of violence.
Since September last year
there have been more than 900 reported killings by armed
political gangs and criminals, despite the presence of a 7,000
plus UN peace-keeping force.
Former Haitian prime
minister, Yvonne Neptune, is expected to be one of the immediate
beneficiaries of this unfolding policy that has come in the face
of the appointment of new United States ambassador assigned to
Port au Prince and with increasing pressures on the interim
regime of Prime Minister Gerard Latortue from the United
Nations.
Arrested since last year
for alleged murder, Neptune, who was prime minister under the
administration of deposed President Jean-Bertrand Aristide, was
only charged after months of protests at home, in the region and
internationally for him to be placed before the courts or be set
free.
 |
| Bertrand Aristide |
A recent significant voice
for the immediate release of Neptune was that, last week, of UN
special envoy to Haiti, Juan Gabriel Valdes, who said the former
Haitian prime minister's continuing imprisonment was a source of
deep concern for Secretary-General Kofi Annan and the UN
Security Council itself, according to a Reuters report.
Latest political
developments suggest a deal that involved key American and
Haitian players for the release of some high-profile political
prisoners who have been associated with killings and political
violence during the administrations of Aristide as well those
that followed the downfall of his government in February 2004
with the support of the USA.
One of the best known of
such prisoners, recently released, is a frontline leader of the
notorious former CIA-funded anti-Aristide organisation, FRAPH,
Louis Jodel Chamblain, who had fled to the USA after Aristide
was returned to power under the Bill Clinton administration.
 |
| Gerard Latortue |
Critics of US policy on
Haiti and of the interim regime in Port au Prince argue that it
is simply untenable to have Chamblain freed from detention while
Neptune remains a prisoner.
Leading human rights
organisations like Amnesty International and Human Rights Watch
continue to point to the threats to Haiti's future by armed
groups, both supporters and opponents of Aristide's Lavalas
Family Party.
Like another controversial,
violent anti-Aristide campaigner and beneficiary of US
intelligence support, Guy Philippe, Chamblain is not without
ambitions for high political office. There will have to be close
monitoring by the UN peace-keeping forces in Haiti to prevent
influential elements like Chamblain and Phillippe disrupting
arrangements for the coming elections.
While the Electoral Council
is pressing ahead - amid continuing political tension and
sporadic killings and violence - to complete an electoral roll
for the parliamentary and presidential elections, those who
remain pessimistic about such elections this year have reminded
that the local government elections, originally scheduled for
October, have already been postponed.
By last week, the Electoral
Council was still below 50 per cent of its targeted four million
eligible voters on the election roll. But the Latortue
administration is hopefully to have at least more than two
million armed with the laminated identification cards in
readiness to vote in the forthcoming parliamentary and
presidential elections.
At the close of nominations
last week, there were some 63 parties registered to contest the
elections, among them that of Aristide's Lavalas, which is still
reputed to be the most popular mass-based organisation of all
contenders for state power.
But Aristide, who remains
in exile in South Africa, will not be in Haiti to assist Lavalas,
which could face an internal leadership problem of its own,
especially in the choice of a presidential candidate.
This possibility looms
larger, according to some Haitian human rights activists, since
the arrest on a charge of murder of the priest and political
activist friend of Aristide, Fr Gerard Jean-Juste.
He is accused of the
kidnapping and murder last month of the popular Haitian
journalist and poet, Jacques Roche, a crime he firmly denies
amid conflicting reports that he was in Miami at the time of
Roche's death.
Kidnappings for ransom has
been on the increase - a concern for the UN peace-keeping
mission, the Latortue regime as well as the US government, which
has allocated some US$2. 5 million to assist the administration
in Port au Prince to expedite the reform over a system that
leads to arbitrary detention and lengthy imprisonment without
charges.
A clear signal that the
Latortue administration and the US State Department might be
signing from the same hymn sheet on ending arbitrary detention,
with pro-Aristide elements and Lavalas activists being affected,
came last week when new Justice Minister Henri Dorlean publicly
declared his opposition to judges and prosecutors misusing their
powers to keep people in prison in violation of Haitian laws.
According to a Reuters
report outof Port au Prince, Dorlean estimated that
approximately 95 per cent of the 1,300 pisoners at the national
penitentiary had been jailed for months without being charged or
tried. A similar situation existing in the country's other
prisons.
Human rights advocates view
Dorlean as a "breath of fresh air" in Latortue's
administration since his replacement in June of the
controversial Bernard Gousse, who was forced to resign. Ex-prime
minister Neptune was one of the leading sufferers of Gousse's
concept of administration of the criminal justice system.
Meanwhile, in another
significant development, the US State Department has decided to
replace Tom Foley, its ambassador to Haiti, with Tim Carney, who
was America's ambassador in Port au Prince during the 1990s.
What perhaps makes Carney's
appointment significant, is the fact that until his nomination
to replace Foley, he was chairman of the Haiti Democracy Project
in Washington, an organisation known for some sharp criticisms
of the George Bush administration's policies and strategies on
Haiti.
However encouraging the
signals from the Latortue regime and its backers in Washington,
the reality is that life for the Haitian masses remain quite
grim as the poverty-stricken nation lurch from crisis to crisis.
Indeed, the prevailing
mood, based on various reports, point to serious doubts that the
coming elections would indeed herald a new beginning for
democratic governance and a brake on political violence,
corruption, fear and grinding poverty.
|