More than 30,000
women and girls - half under the age of 18 - were
raped in Haiti's capital city in the chaotic two
years following the ousting of the country's
democratically elected president, a survey has
suggested. About 8,000 people were killed during the
same period.
The survey highlights
the extraordinary violence at a time when the
country was headed by an interim government imposed
by the international community, following the
enforced departure of Jean-Bertrand Aristide.
"Our results indicate that crime and systematic
abuse of human rights were common in [the capital]
Port-au-Prince," the researchers from Wayne
State University in Michigan said. "Although
criminals were the most identified perpetrators of
violations, political actors and UN soldiers were
also frequently identified.
"These findings
suggest the need for a systematic response from the
newly elected Haitian government, the UN and social
service organisations to address the ...
consequences of human rights abuses."
Mr Aristide was
forced from power in February 2004 by a coalition of
former soldiers, members of the business community
and US-backed political opponents. Following
elections earlier this year, Rene Preval, a former
president, was chosen to again lead the country.
The survey, based on
random sampling and extrapolation, suggests that
between February 2004 and December 2005, a total of
35,000 women were sexually assaulted. Of those
attacks, 90 per cent involved rapes. The survey,
published in The Lancet, does not make any
comparison to the incidence of rape and killing
prior to Mr Aristide's ousting. However, both the
report's authors and other human rights workers said
they believe the level of rape is directly linked to
a high level of general violence and lawlessness -
conditions that existed in abundance during the
interim government period.
"Unfortunately,
I think the rates are higher than we had
anticipated," said one of the study's authors,
Professor Royce Hutson.
He said that, while
around half of rape perpetrators were identified as
"general criminals", about 14 per cent
were members of the Haitian National Police (HNP), a
further 12 per cent as members of anti-Aristide
groups, with about 25 per cent unidentified. He said
the involvement of people with political links and
the police suggested something
"systematic" may have been taking place.
Of the 8,000 killings
- a rate that would give the interim government one
of the worst human rights records in the hemisphere
- 22 per cent were committed by the police, 26 per
cent by the demobilised army or armed anti-Aristide
groups and 48 per cent by criminals. Both the HNP
and members of the demobilised army acted against
supporters of Mr Aristide and his Lavalas party.
Despite the election
of Mr Preval, violence and rape has continued. Last
Friday several hundred rape victims marched through
the centre of Port-au-Prince, their faces covered by
veils, to highlight the ongoing crisis. Organiser
Eramithe Delva, of the Commission of Women Victims
for Victims (KOFAVIV), said: "We are veiling
our faces because this is how they come to our homes
to rape us, beat us, destroy our homes, burn our
things."
Anne Sosin, of the
group Vizyon Dwa Ayisyen (Haiti Rights Vision),
said: "Cases of rape have increased
dramatically during the past two years. Rape is not
being used a tool of political repression in the way
it was during the 1991-94 period, where women were
targeted because of their political activities or
that of their husbands. These rapes are happening in
the context of the current political crisis and are
being perpetrated by groups that often have links to
political actors."
The survey does not
identify Lavalas supporters as being involved in any
rapes or killings, although such people could be
included in other categories. Brian Concannon, of
the Haiti Support Group, said: "There are cases
where family members have reported, during the same
period, that Lavalas supporters and foreign soldiers
are responsible for killings. The cases must be
infrequent enough to not necessarily show up on this
type of survey."
History of rape
and murder
Sexual assault as a
form of political repression has a long history in
Haiti. A court in New York last week heard evidence
against Emmanuel "Toto" Constant, a
Haitian now living in the US, who led military death
squads that raped and tortured followers of
President Jean-Bertrand Aristide in the early 1990s.
Under the military
regime that ruled Haiti between 1991-94, the
paramilitary group Front for the Advancement and
Progress of Haiti (FRAPH) was responsible for a wave
of killing and rape. In 2004, three unidentified
women filed a lawsuit against Mr Constant. The
hearing in New York was to determine whether Mr
Constant owes damages to three women. He is in
prison on mortgage fraud charges and did not attend
the hearing.
One of the three
woman told the court that masked men had burst into
her home in Port-au-Prince in 1994 and raped her
while her children saw "everything that was
being done to me". She gave her evidence
through a translator and from behind a screen, to
hide her identity.
In 1996 the US State
Department allowed Mr Constant to avoid deportation
to Haiti and live freely in the US despite his
position as head of FRAPH. Mr Constant says he
worked for the CIA at the time.
More than 30,000
women and girls - half under the age of 18 - were
raped in Haiti's capital city in the chaotic two
years following the ousting of the country's
democratically elected president, a survey has
suggested. About 8,000 people were killed during the
same period.
The survey highlights
the extraordinary violence at a time when the
country was headed by an interim government imposed
by the international community, following the
enforced departure of Jean-Bertrand Aristide.
"Our results indicate that crime and systematic
abuse of human rights were common in [the capital]
Port-au-Prince," the researchers from Wayne
State University in Michigan said. "Although
criminals were the most identified perpetrators of
violations, political actors and UN soldiers were
also frequently identified.
"These findings
suggest the need for a systematic response from the
newly elected Haitian government, the UN and social
service organisations to address the ...
consequences of human rights abuses."
Mr Aristide was
forced from power in February 2004 by a coalition of
former soldiers, members of the business community
and US-backed political opponents. Following
elections earlier this year, Rene Preval, a former
president, was chosen to again lead the country.
The survey, based on
random sampling and extrapolation, suggests that
between February 2004 and December 2005, a total of
35,000 women were sexually assaulted. Of those
attacks, 90 per cent involved rapes. The survey,
published in The Lancet, does not make any
comparison to the incidence of rape and killing
prior to Mr Aristide's ousting. However, both the
report's authors and other human rights workers said
they believe the level of rape is directly linked to
a high level of general violence and lawlessness -
conditions that existed in abundance during the
interim government period.
"Unfortunately,
I think the rates are higher than we had
anticipated," said one of the study's authors,
Professor Royce Hutson.
He said that, while
around half of rape perpetrators were identified as
"general criminals", about 14 per cent
were members of the Haitian National Police (HNP), a
further 12 per cent as members of anti-Aristide
groups, with about 25 per cent unidentified. He said
the involvement of people with political links and
the police suggested something
"systematic" may have been taking place.
Of the 8,000 killings
- a rate that would give the interim government one
of the worst human rights records in the hemisphere
- 22 per cent were committed by the police, 26 per
cent by the demobilised army or armed anti-Aristide
groups and 48 per cent by criminals. Both the HNP
and members of the demobilised army acted against
supporters of Mr Aristide and his Lavalas party.